NINoritake Ito

Business disputes in Japan

Removal of a Director in Japan: Damages for the Remaining Term

A shareholders' meeting of a Japanese company can remove a director at any time. Article 339(1) of the Companies Act says so, and there is no argument to be had about it.

What foreign executives are usually not told is the next sentence. A director removed during their term without justifiable grounds may claim damages from the company (Article 339(2)).

This matters because the removal itself is valid either way. You do not get your seat back. But the company may owe you money for having taken it, and the measure of that money starts from the compensation you would have received for the rest of your term.

If you were brought into a Japanese company as a director, CxO or country head on a fixed term and were removed partway through, this is the first thing to establish.

The short version

  • The removal is effective. The damages claim is separate and survives it.
  • The starting point for damages is the compensation you would have earned for the unexpired portion of the term.
  • Director compensation in Japan requires the articles of incorporation or a shareholders' resolution. Whether that resolution exists, and what it says, is the first document to find.
  • Resigning instead of being removed generally gives this claim away.

What counts as "justifiable grounds"

This is where the case is won or lost.

Japanese courts have treated the following as capable of amounting to justifiable grounds: misconduct in the performance of duties, breach of law or of the articles of incorporation, physical or mental incapacity preventing performance, and failure of management judgement where it rises to the level of a marked lack of capability.

What is generally not sufficient, standing alone, is a difference of view about strategy, or conflict with a controlling shareholder. Being outvoted by the majority is the normal operation of a company, not a justification for avoiding the consequence the statute attaches.

In practice the company tends to assemble reasons afterwards. That makes two things important: what was actually said to you at the time of removal, and what was discussed at the board or shareholders' meeting. Contemporaneous documents usually say something different from the litigation position.

How the damages are measured

The starting point is the compensation you would have received for the remainder of the term. If the term was two years and eighteen months remained, that eighteen months of compensation is the base.

From there, several things are argued:

  • Retirement allowance — whether there is a practice or internal rule providing for one
  • Mitigation — whether income you earned elsewhere after removal is deducted
  • Employee status — if you were a director who was also an employee, what happens to the employment side

Because the term length drives the number, the articles of incorporation, the commercial register and the resolution appointing you all have to be checked. Terms for directors of Japanese companies vary, and a company with restricted share transfers can extend them considerably.

When the compensation itself was never paid

A related and very common situation: the compensation was agreed but never properly authorised.

Article 361 of the Companies Act requires director compensation to be fixed by the articles of incorporation or by a shareholders' resolution. The usual practice is for the shareholders to approve an aggregate ceiling and leave the allocation among directors to the board.

The problem arises when nothing was ever resolved and the figure exists only in an offer letter or an oral agreement. The company may then argue that no concrete claim to compensation ever arose.

That argument does not always succeed. Where payments were actually made, or internal records show the company decided the amount, there may be a basis to say the company's will was formed. The offer letter, the minutes and the actual bank transfer history have to be read together.

A unilateral reduction in compensation raises a different question — whether you consented to it.

Challenging the removal itself

Where the resolution was procedurally defective — notice of the meeting, quorum, the counting of votes — there are routes to challenge its effect.

Whether that is worth doing is a separate question. If the other side controls the company, the shares and the bank accounts, restoring your title rarely restores your position.

In most matters the realistic objective is money and a clean set of exit terms: the remaining term's compensation, unpaid compensation and bonus, the treatment of stock options and shares, the scope of any non-compete, and what the company says publicly about your departure. Those are negotiated together, as set out in negotiating a founder or executive exit.

What to gather, and why timing matters

  • The articles of incorporation and a certified copy of the commercial register (these establish the appointment date and the term)
  • Minutes of the shareholders' and board meetings appointing you, the delegation agreement, the offer letter
  • Everything about how compensation was fixed: shareholder resolution, board resolution, compensation rules
  • The removal notice, the notice convening the shareholders' meeting, and the minutes
  • Performance material — including anything the company might later rely on as justifiable grounds
  • The correspondence leading up to the removal

Once you are off the board you lose access to the company's systems. The register and the articles can be obtained afterwards. Internal documents generally cannot. If removal is foreseeable, this is the point at which to secure what you are entitled to keep — bearing in mind that preserving your own evidence is not the same as taking the company's confidential information.

The company has asked me to resign instead. Should I?

Resignation and removal are legally different, and the difference has a price.

If you resign, a claim under Article 339(2) generally does not arise. Signing a resignation letter before the exit terms are settled gives away the leverage you have.

That does not make resignation wrong — a negotiated resignation on agreed terms is often the sensible outcome. It makes signing it first, before anything else is agreed, the mistake.

The business did badly on my watch. Does that end it?

Not necessarily. Poor results are not automatically justifiable grounds. The question is whether the failure of management judgement reached the level of a marked lack of capability.

It also matters whether the company gave that reason at the time. A justification produced for the first time in a letter from the company's lawyers, months later, carries less weight than one recorded in the minutes.

The company's lawyer has contacted me. Can I reply myself?

You can, but what you write may be used later.

Be particularly careful with anything that accepts the company's account of why you were removed, or that characterises your departure as voluntary. If a deadline has been set, that is usually a reason to take advice quickly rather than to answer quickly.

Can I claim unpaid compensation and removal damages together?

They are legally different claims, but they are normally pursued in the same negotiation or proceedings.

How the total is built affects which procedure makes sense and what it costs, so it is worth settling the full picture before sending anything.

If you are not Japanese and were appointed to a Japanese company

Two further points come up regularly.

Your status of residence may be tied to the role. Where a work-based status depends on the contract with the employing organisation, the end of that relationship has immigration consequences and notification deadlines of its own. I do not handle immigration applications, but the two need to be sequenced rather than dealt with one after the other.

And the governing law of your service agreement may name another country. Between a company and its director that clause is generally respected, but the Companies Act questions above — removal, the compensation resolution, the damages claim — attach to the Japanese company itself regardless of what your personal contract says.

Related

Other guides in this series

Leaving a Japanese Company as a Founder or Executive: What to Negotiate

Agreeing to leave settles nothing if the shares, the options, the unpaid compensation and the non-compete are all still open.

When the Earn-Out or Deferred Consideration Is Not Paid

Not whether the business performed, but what the contract's own calculation produces — and whether the buyer's conduct got in the way.

Unpaid Freelance Fees in Japan: What to Do When a Japanese Client Does Not Pay

Claiming without a signed contract, defect allegations, the Freelancer Act's 60-day rule, and the five steps from preserving evidence to court.

Contract Termination in Japan: Rights of Foreign Freelancers and Independent Contractors

Four separate questions behind a termination email, and what to preserve before your access to the client's systems disappears.

Stock Option and Equity Disputes in Japanese Startups

Whether options were legally issued or only promised, what vesting does not answer, and why a headline valuation is not the measure of the loss.

Founder and Business Partner Disputes in Japan

One dispute is usually several: shares, board seat, founder loans, IP and customers. Separating them before choosing a strategy.

Recovering Loans and Investment Money in Japan

A failed investment is not automatically a debt. Identifying the legal basis, the right defendant, and the warning signs that recovery is slipping away.

Overview: business disputes in Japan for foreign professionals, founders and investors →

Contact

Discuss Your Business Dispute in Japan

If you are a foreign professional, founder or investor involved in a dispute with a Japanese company or business partner, the first step is usually to identify the relevant contract, evidence and legal relationship.

English-language contracts and communications can be reviewed together with the applicable Japanese legal issues.

Typical matters include:

  • unpaid freelance and consulting fees
  • termination of independent contractor agreements
  • stock option and equity disputes
  • founder and shareholder disputes
  • joint business disputes
  • loan and investment recovery

Please contact me with a brief explanation of the dispute and the key documents available. Please read the engagement policy first; contacting me does not create an attorney–client relationship, which begins only when we sign an engagement letter.

Go to the contact form


This article provides general information about Japanese law and does not constitute legal advice for any particular matter. The applicable rules and available remedies depend on the facts, contractual terms and other circumstances of each case.